Bollards are essential elements in managing traffic flow, enhancing security, and defining spaces in various environments. Two common types of bollards are the removable bollards and the retractable (telescopic) bollards. Both offer flexibility in access control but differ in their design and functionality and can have different roles in managing your space.
We wanted to explore the differences between removable and retractable bollards and their pros and cons to help you decide which type best suits your needs. However, keep in mind that, in our experience, you often need both types deployed strategically across your premises for optimal results.
Removable Bollards
As the name suggests, removable bollards are designed to be easily installed and removed when needed. They typically consist of a bollard post of varied thickness, which goes into a sleeve installed in the ground. Once the sleeve is in, you only need to insert the bollard post into it when access control is required and remove it when you don't need it anymore.
Additionally, it is good to know that sometimes removable bollards are anchored in place with a locking mechanism or secured using a special base plate installed in the ground. Lastly, the hole left by the missing bollard is often covered with a flap so that removal doesn't leave an unsightly gap.
Overall, non-permanent bollards are a great tool for traffic management, as they can be inexpensive, quick to deal with and easy to manage.
What Are The Pros of Removable Bollards
Versatility
Removable bollards offer flexibility in controlling temporary access to designated areas, making them suitable for occasional vehicle access. They are versatile and can be installed in many commercial and private properties to make your life easier.
Cost-Effective
Installation costs for removable bollards are generally lower than other non-permanent types of bollards. This makes them a cost-effective option as they are so budget-friendly.
Low Maintenance
Removable bollards have fewer mechanical components; therefore, there are simply fewer things that can break. This makes them easy to maintain and typically requires less care over time. They are also a one-off installation event – once the sleeve is in, there is no need for further groundwork, which means that the whole job is done very quickly and efficiently.
What Are The Cons of Removable Bollards
Manual Operation
To do the removal of a removable bollard, you need to lift and insert it every time by hand. This requires a bit of effort, especially for heavier-duty models, and may be inconvenient to you. This is especially true if the bollards are installed in a place where they need to be in and out repeatedly.
Security Risk
It is worth remembering that removable bollards are less secure and strong compared to non-removable models. They are not anchored to a permanent foundation, making them more vulnerable to being knocked over or dislodged when hit by a vehicle. Consider this if you are buying bollards for security and property protection.
Storage
Removable bollards need to be stored somewhere when not in use. Once the pole is removed, you will need to find a place to put it until it can go back in the sleeve. This may be an inconvenience, so it is worth remembering that it is something that needs to be planned for.
Use Cases
-
Creating temporary pedestrian zones during events or festivals
-
Loading zones for trucks and delivery vehicles
-
Emergency vehicle access routes
Retractable Bollards
Retractable bollards are another type of non-permanent bollards, but they are designed to retract into the ground when not in use as opposed to being entirely removed. Once into the ground, they allow unimpeded access to designated areas.
They typically feature a hydraulic or manual lifting mechanism that enables the bollard to be raised or lowered as needed. Telescopic bollards are convenient to use, secure, typically more robust, and more resistant to damage.
What Are The Pros of Retractable Bollards
Automated Operation
Not all retractable bollards are automated; some are manually operated, like the Heavy Duty Retractable Bollard, and others are lift-assisted. But some retractable bollards do indeed offer the convenience of automated operation, allowing for quick and easy access control without the need for physical intervention. This makes them an excellent choice when you need bollards installed in a place where they need to go up and down very often, and manual operation would be a significant inconvenience.
Enhanced Security
Retractable bollards provide a higher security level than removable bollards, as they are less susceptible to tampering and unauthorised removal when lowered. They are anchored to the ground at all times, so during an impact, they are more likely to stay in place and do their job to protect your property.
Durability
Retractable bollards are designed to withstand heavy-duty usage and harsh environmental conditions. They are made to offer long-term reliability and performance and are a good choice for places where security and strength are paramount, and bollards are not just for managing parking and traffic.
What Are The Cons of Retractable Bollards
Cost
Retractable bollards tend to have higher installation costs than removable bollards. Their increased cost is primarily due to the additional mechanical components and automation systems.
Maintenance Requirements
As we said, with the removable bollards – there are fewer moving parts and fewer things that can break. However, telescopic bollards are a bit more susceptible to wear and tear especially the automatic ones. The mechanical components of retractable bollards may require some maintenance over time to ensure proper operation and longevity.
Use Cases
-
Access control for restricted areas in high-security facilities
-
Pedestrian-only zones in urban environments
-
Secure entry points for government buildings or military installations
Both removable and retractable bollards offer effective access control solutions, catering to different needs and scenarios. Removable bollards are versatile and cost-effective, suitable for temporary access control requirements, while retractable bollards provide enhanced security and convenience with automated operation and durability. By understanding each type's pros, cons, and use cases, property owners can choose the option that best aligns with their specific requirements for traffic management, security, and accessibility.